25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (2024)

25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (1)What would Christmas be without candy? Whether you normally make your own or buy it in the store, you just have to have those delicious bits of chocolate and confections around the house during the holiday season.

We have collected a great list of make it yourself Christmas candies that are sure to please everyone this season. Whether you prefer to leave them all in the candy dish or you want to add a little special to someone’s gift and give them a selection of your homemade candies, there are recipes here that are easy to make and look as good as they taste.

Christmas candy is a wonderful gift choice for teachers, coworkers and just anyone on your list who has a bit of a sweet tooth. Make a selection and wrap it all up in a nice basket and you have the perfect gift for someone who seems to have everything. The best part is that most of the candies on our list are really easy to make and only need a few key ingredients. So, get busy making your favorites from the list or make them all and surprise someone with a gift of homemade goodness this Christmas.

Candy Cane Sugar Cookies

Pretty easy to do lovely cookies that will definitely make you stand out! BHG provides easy to follow instructions and it can be done in an hour!

Recipe and Source - Better Home and Gardens

25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (2)

Candy Cane Marshmallow Pops

Candy canes, marshmallows, chocolate and nuts – nothing says Christmas more than this! These little pops are so easy to make. You just dip a marshmallow in melted chocolate, roll it in nuts, sprinkles, coconut or whatever you want and then just stick the candy cane into the marshmallow for a stick. They would be cute sticking off the side of a cup of hot chocolate.
Recipe and Source - Livlifetoo 25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (3)

Peanut Butter Balls

Chocolate peanut butter balls or buckeyes are a popular Christmas candy. They are relatively easy to make and simply melt in your mouth with deliciousness. You need ingredients like powdered sugar, chocolate chips, peanut butter and shortening and although they look complicated, they are actually one of the easiest homemade candies that you can make.
Recipe and Source -shewearsmanyhats25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (4)

Yummy Candied Caramels

You can take regular caramel squares that you buy in the store and then use sprinkles, chocolate, nuts and other ingredients to give them a homemade touch. Just use lollipop sticks and dip them in chocolate or white chocolate and add the decorations that you want. They are easy to make and oh-so-yummy and are the perfect gift giving candy.
Recipe and Source - Bhg 25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (5)

Homemade Hard Candy

Homemade hard candy or rock candy is really simply to make. You just need the key ingredients which include sugar and flavoring oils, which you can purchase at many hobby stores and at most Wal-Mart stores. You do need a candy thermometer to ensure that the candy cooks to the perfect temperature but aside from that, it’s really easy to make homemade rock candy and you can make different flavors to make everyone happy.
Recipe and Source - Serendipitymommy 25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (6)

Peppermint Patties

Oh the taste of chocolate covered peppermint! If you love York peppermint patties, this is the perfect candy recipe for you. It calls for cream cheese, peppermint flavoring, chocolate and a few other key ingredients and you can choose to color the inside green or leave it white. You can also choose to dip them in chocolate or let them stand alone as peppermint candies – the possibilities with this one are endless.
Recipe and Source - Lovepomegranatehouse 25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (7)

Peanut Brittle

Peanut brittle is a classic Christmas candy that is so great for gift-giving. You can fill a Christmas tin with peanut brittle and make virtually anyone on your Christmas list happy. The best thing is that this candy is so very simple to make. You just have to crystalize the sugar and add peanuts. You can also use almonds or any other kind of nut you want to make it a bit unique.
Recipe and Source - Marthastewart 25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (8)

Peppermint Bark

Peppermint bark is another candy that is easy to make. You just have to melt chocolate and white chocolate, layer them and then add crushed peppermint. You can also make this by adding melted white chocolate to peppermint and Rice Krispies and then layering it onto melted dark chocolate. If you want, you can decorate with things like marshmallows, crushed candies or just anything you prefer.
Recipe and Source - Cookingontheside 25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (9)

Marshmallow Pops

If you want a really easy to make sucker type candy and something that they kids can help with, these marshmallow pops are perfect. You just insert a sucker stick into a marshmallow, dip in white chocolate or chocolate and then decorate however you wish. You can use nuts or sprinkles or go all out and create snowmen, Santa and other characters.
Recipe and Source - Iwashyoudry 25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (10)

Homemade Almond Joy

This is a great, and really versatile, candy to make. If you love the taste of Almond Joy, you will love this recipe. You can choose to make it into bars or roll it into balls if you want and then dip in chocolate. You can also choose not to use chocolate at all or dip them in white chocolate, whatever your preference. The recipe is really easy to make and the combination of almonds and roasted coconut is delicious.
Recipe and Source - Measuredbytheheart 25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (11)

Candy Cane Marshmallows

Did you know that you can make your own marshmallows? This candy cane peppermint marshmallow recipe is great and homemade marshmallows are the perfect choice for adding to cocoa mixes if you are giving those as a gift. You make them in a baking dish and then cut them whatever size you want. Or, if you want to be really creative you could use Christmas themed candy molds to shape them.
Recipe and Source - Familyfreshcooking 25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (12)

Easy Toffee

You can make toffee easily with sugar, chocolate chips, butter and saltine crackers. The crackers give it a wonderful crunch and this candy is one of the simplest to make. You just bake and then melt chocolate to cover, freeze and cut or break apart. You can add pecans or other nuts if you like or even use white chocolate if dark chocolate isn’t your preference.
Recipe and Source - Thenourishinggourmet 25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (13)

Reindeer Noses

Kids will adore these reindeer noses for their looks as well as their taste. You just need small pretzels (square ones work really well), M&M candies and chocolate kisses. Just top each pretzel with a Hershey’s Kiss and bake until melted. Then press a red or green M&M into the center and you have a tasty treat that is as adorable to look at as it is yummy.
Recipe and Source - Food.com 25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (14)

Homemade Butter Mints

What a great gift idea! You can make these homemade butter mints and then fill Mason jars, decorate and you have something very unique and very tasty to give away this Christmas. The mints require powdered sugar, whipping cream, peppermint oil and a few other ingredients and you can use food coloring to make them any combination of colors that you want.
Recipe and Source - Justapinch 25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (15)

Cappuccino Caramels

Coffee, sweetened condensed milk and brown sugar combine to make yummy chocolate caramels. Add pecans or any other nuts that you want and you have a very tasty treat to sample or give away as gifts. These are relatively easy to make and look great stacked in a Christmas tin. Add a few other chocolate candies and you have the perfect gift.
Recipe and Source - Eaglebrand 25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (16)

Homemade Potato Candy

Bring back memories when you make this wonderful and traditional potato candy for Christmas. This is one of the easiest candies of all time to make. You just boil a medium potato until done, add powdered sugar and then layer out. Spread the layer with peanut butter and roll into a jelly roll shape. Cut into slices and enjoy. This is a pretty candy that is so yummy you will want to keep a bit for yourself and give a bit away.
Recipe and Source - Blazeinonlifeonawannabefarm 25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (17)

Homemade Cherry Cordials

Chocolate covered cherries are very much a Christmas tradition in many households. You can make them yourself and add your own new tradition. You can actually make the basic candy recipe and then flavor it in different ways so you have different candies all from one recipe. What a great gift to give or a yummy treat to keep at home!
Recipe and Source - Countrymommacooks 25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (18)

Easy 3 Ingredient Christmas Fudge

When it comes to making Christmas candy, sometimes easier is much better. This yummy fudge uses only three ingredients – white chocolate, candy canes and sweetened condensed milk. You just melt the chocolate with the milk, add the peppermint candies and then allow it to harden. It is yummy and looks very festive so you can use it for your gift giving – just fill a tin or jar with the fudge, add a festive bow and you’re all set.
Recipe and Source - Snapcracklechop 25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (19)

Brazilian Chocolate Truffles

Truffles really do make wonderful gifts. You can take the same recipe and depending on how you finish it off, have so many different candies to give away. Top your truffles in sprinkles, coconut, crushed nuts or practically anything you want. These store in the refrigerator for up to a week or out on the counter for a few days so they are perfect for setting out during holiday get-togethers.
Recipe and Source - Bettycrocker 25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (20)

Traditional Chocolate Fudge

Chocolate fudge is one of those Christmas candy musts. You know that it’s just not the holiday season without some yummy chocolate fudge to nibble on. Old-fashioned fudge is not nearly as difficult to make as many people believe and there are so many variations that are just as easy. Whether you choose to keep your fudge or give it away as a gift, you know you’ll just have to make a batch this season.
Recipe and Source - Whatsgabycooking 25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (21)

Candy Cane Hearts

You can take mini candy canes and chocolate and create the most adorable candies or lollipops. You just have to place two mini candy canes together so that they form a heart and then fill in the inside with chocolate or white chocolate. Add a lollipop stick before you add melted chocolate and it will make the perfect pop. Then just decorate with sprinkles, nuts, crushed candies or whatever you want.
Recipe and Source - Glorioustreats 25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (22)

Turkish Delight

What a delicious candy! Turkish delight will simply melt in your mouth and there is a great recipe that uses pomegranate which is really healthy. The colors of the candy, particularly when you top it with powdered sugar, are beautiful and make the perfect give away candy for gifts. Just layer a tin with Turkish Delight or add a combination of different candies that you have made.
Recipe and Source - Veganfeastkitchen 25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (23)

Easy Peppermint Sticks

If you want really easy candy, these peppermint sticks fit the bill. You just dip the ends in chocolate or white chocolate and then dip in sprinkles, crushed nuts or crushed candies. Wrap then individually in plastic wrap and fill a Christmas themed mug with them for the perfect gift for teachers, particularly when you add some homemade hot chocolate mix.
Recipe and Source - Bhg 25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (24)

Homemade Snow Caps

What says Christmas better than snow? These homemade snow caps are easy to make and are beautiful to look at so they make a wonderful gift giving choice. Do them in chocolate and white chocolate to have different looks and then use Christmas colored sprinkles to make them really festive.
Recipe and Source - Celebrations 25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (25)

Homemade Gumdrops

Yummy gumdrops are a wonderful Christmas candy choice. These are made with applesauce so they are relatively healthy and you can do them in several different ways. Either layer them out and cut them into squares or pour them into Christmas candy molds and make them a bit more festive. You can use different colors of food coloring to have a colorful look no matter how many different flavors you choose to make.
Recipe and Source - Tasteofhome 25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (26)

Homemade Crunch Bars

Love Nestle Crunch Bars? You can make your own and even use them to give away as holiday gifts. These yummy bars will be a great hit at your office Christmas party or you can let the kids leave a few out for Santa. They take very little time to make and you can either pour them into a pan and cut into squares or get really creative and use Christmas molds to make them unique.
Recipe and Source - Lynnskitchenadventures 25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (27)

Ready for more? Check out our other Christmassycollections and tutorials.

20 Hopelessly Adorable DIY Christmas Ornaments Made from Paper
Cute and Easy Christmas Craft: DIY Plastic Spoon Snowmen
60 Beautifully Festive Ways to Decorate Your Porch for Christmas
50+ Creative Christmas Printables Collection
15 Easy And Festive DIY Christmas Ornaments
40 Amazing Christmas Gift Wrapping Ideas You can Make Yourself
100 Mind-Blowing DIY Christmas Gifts People Actually Want
10 Insanely Easy Christmas Light Bulb Decorations and Ornaments
33 Festive Christmas Wreaths You Can Easily DIY
10 Fun and Easy Way to Dress Up Christmas Ornaments
12 Super Cute DIY Christmas Hairstyles for All Lengths
Adorable Christmas Decoration: DIY Cotton Thread Snowman
10 Genius DIY Ways to Transform Pinecones into Holiday Decorations

25 Yummy Homemade Christmas Candy Recipes (2024)


Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Kareem Mueller DO

Last Updated:

Views: 6542

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (66 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Kareem Mueller DO

Birthday: 1997-01-04

Address: Apt. 156 12935 Runolfsdottir Mission, Greenfort, MN 74384-6749

Phone: +16704982844747

Job: Corporate Administration Planner

Hobby: Mountain biking, Jewelry making, Stone skipping, Lacemaking, Knife making, Scrapbooking, Letterboxing

Introduction: My name is Kareem Mueller DO, I am a vivacious, super, thoughtful, excited, handsome, beautiful, combative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.